• 77°

Column: Plenty of worries heading into Run for the Roses

Not everyone sees horse racing the same way

FILE – In this May 17, 2009, file photo, Nicole Matthews holds a placard as she walks past her fellow PETA protesters outside Pimlico Race Course as they call attention to the death of Kentucky Derby second placed horse, Eight Belles, who was euthanized following the race, as they protest before the 133rd Preakness horse race in Baltimore. Horse racing finds itself under intense scrutiny at a time of year when the Kentucky Derby kicks off the Triple Crown series and interest among the general public is at its highest. The deaths of 23 horses over three months at Santa Anita in California have roiled an industry already battered by declining attendance, increased competition for gambling dollars, and the ire of animal rights activists.(AP Photo/Mel Evans, File)

By PAUL NEWBERRY AP Sports Columnist
LOUISVILLE, Ky. (AP) — The famed garland of red roses will be draped over the horse that crosses the line first in the Kentucky Derby.
It would be an even bigger triumph if all 19 of these marvelous animals make it under the wire safely.
As horse racing prepares for its biggest day, everyone around Churchill Downs is holding their breath just a bit.
The one thing the sport can’t afford is another tragedy.
A dark cloud has settled over the sport of kings in recent months, and we’re not even talking about a stormy forecast that might turn the track into a muddy mess come Saturday.
On the West Coast, a rash of deaths during the winter racing season led to a temporary shutdown at famed Santa Anita and fueled an increasingly bellicose crusade by animal-right activists who want to put a pursuit they see as inhumane out to pasture.
If, heaven forbid, another horse should break down with more than 100,000 watching in the stands and millions more tuning in on NBC, it might be time to acknowledge that racing is truly — and deservedly — in the homestretch of its very existence.
While the scratching of favorite Omaha Beach was a huge disappointment, it also was an encouraging indication that horse racing realizes the stakes have never been higher.
Nothing is more important than the health and safety of the horses, along with those who ride them.
Not even the Kentucky Derby, one of the rare days when this niche sport goes mainstream.
“When you learn about horse racing, the first thing you learn is the Kentucky Derby,” said Richard Mandella, the Hall of Fame trainer for Omaha Beach. “Whether you are a jockey or trainer or groom, a hot walker, an owner, it doesn’t matter. The Kentucky Derby is what everybody knows. Everybody has that dream to win it.”
But when Mandella’s horse was having trouble breathing, he made the decision to pull him out of the race. It was a gut-wrenching call, for both the trainer and the colt’s owner.
Mandella has never won the Derby with six previous starters. At his age, this very well could be his final shot. Ditto for the colt’s 78-year-old owner, Rick Porter. He is a cancer survivor who has twice finished second in the Derby, including the tragic year of 2008 when his filly, Eight Belles, broke her front legs after crossing the finish line and had to be euthanized.
“Horsemen care for their animals,” Mandella said. “We don’t always get the warning and things happen. But horsemen always look for the warning signs and don’t want to do the wrong thing.”
With that in mind, longshot Haikal joined Omaha Beach on the scratched list Friday morning because of an abscess in his left front hoof.
Omaha Beach had trained well and shown no signs of distress during his time on the track at Churchill Downs. But after the colt developed a cough, a veterinary exam revealed an entrapped epiglottis. While generally not a career-threatening condition, it does have to be corrected with minor surgery.
That means this Omaha Beach won’t compete in any of the Triple Crown events.
“As bad as it felt” to scratch the horse, Mandella said, “it would be a horrible feeling to have him not finish well and know that I was at fault for running him.”
If this sport is to survive, that is the mantra everyone must adopt.
Tighter rules and regulations are fine, and some sort of national governing body is sorely needed, but none of that will matter if human beings don’t do the right thing. There’s no way to keep an eye on every farm, every barn, every stall.
Death at the racetrack is hardly a new phenomenon, of course. Ruffian died from injuries sustained in a highly publicized match race in 1975. Barbaro shattered a leg during the 2006 Preakness and succumbed to the injuries about eight months later. And then there was Eight Belles, horribly breaking down while being slowed after completing the Derby, leading to her being put to death right on the track.
Yet, those always seemed like isolated incidents. The gruesome season at Santa Anita, where 23 horses have perished since the day after Christmas, cast a spotlight on enormity of the problem, which clearly extends far beyond a single track.
Activist Patrick Battuello says that thousands of racing horses die every year in the U.S., a grim toll that he painstakingly documents on his https://horseracingwrongs.com web site.
He lists 817 horses that were killed while racing or training in 2018, plus another 100 that died on track grounds from what were described as non-racing ailments. So far in 2019, the list includes 84 horses killed while racing or training and another 12 that died on track grounds, which sounds like a significant decline until Battuello points out that countless deaths are sure to be added to the list after he files his annual flurry of freedom-of-information requests at the end of the year.
Not surprisingly, Churchill Downs announced a series of safety initiatives two weeks ago, including a new $8 million equine medical center, a proposal to eliminate use of the disputed drug Lasix on race days, and additional camera surveillance of all track facilities. But all of those will take a year or longer to implement, meaning they won’t have any impact on this year’s Derby.
So hold your breath.
When the gate springs open on Saturday, all we can do is hope everyone makes it back alive.
___
Paul Newberry is a sports columnist for The Associated Press. Write to him at pnewberry@ap.org or at www.twitter.com/pnewberry1963 His work can be found at https://apnews.com/search/paul%20newberry
___
More AP sports: https://apnews.com/apf-sports and https://twitter.com/AP_Sports

Comments

Local

Local scouts sweep NC American Legion awards

Business

As demand lessens slightly, local homebuilders work through challenges to deliver dwellings

Local

Commissioners name Newberry Hall House county’s newest historic landmark

College

Livingstone College alumna Quanera Hayes makes U.S. Olympic Team after first-place finish in 400-meter race

Crime

Blotter: June 21

Ask Us

Ask Us: What is status of ‘speed table’ on Charles Street in Spencer?

Local

East Rowan High graduate killed in motorcycle crash

Local

Political Notebook: Gov. Cooper vetoes Ford-backed bill allowing firearms at churches that are also schools

Crime

Blotter: June 20

News

Body of fourth tuber, age 7, found in North Carolina river

Nation/World

8 kids in youth van among the 13 lives lost to Claudette

Local

Hundreds turn out for annual Juneteenth celebration on newest federal holiday

Local

Between local champions and an upcoming state tournament, pickleball putting Salisbury on map

Business

Business leaders hope to draw big crowd for job fair at West End Plaza

News

Officers cleared in Mooresville shooting

Business

From firefighter to photographer, Brianna Mitschele is ready to capture more moments in downtown Salisbury

News

25 years later, runners reflect on Olympic torch’s trip through Rowan

News

Commissioners to consider designating Newberry Hall House as county historic landmark

Farm & Garden

51st annual Old Southeast Threshers’ Reunion set for July 1-5

Business

Biz Roundup: St. Luke’s Episcopal Church Foundation awards grants from Salisbury to Jerusalem

Lifestyle

Kristy Woodson Harvey: For Dad

News

South Salisbury Fire Department activates new weather siren

Lifestyle

Library Notes: Meet the ‘Dare Devil Dogs’ in Week 5

Faith

Q&A with Bishop Tim Smith